Update: SD proposes abortion ban



Re: Talking about SD proposes abortion ban


SD proposes abortion ban

On the 33rd anniversary of Roe v. Wade, as demonstrators march on Washington both for and against abortion, it is worth noting that the South Dakota legislature is going to try another attempt at banning abortions in their state.  I find it most notable that this bill is titled the "Woman’s Health and Life Protection Act".  It reveals the awareness of the damage abortions do to the mother, both physically and psychologically. 
 Looks like South Dakota has started a trend.  According to a UPI article in the Washington Times, at least five states are now ready to pass strict anti-abortion legislation.
Sweeping anti-abortion laws proposed
Jan. 31, 2006 at 9:28AM
      Legislators in at least five states are proposing bold anti-abortion measures as the Bush administration reshapes the U.S. Supreme Court, a report said.
      With the goal of challenging the Roe vs. Wade ruling that ensured a woman’s right to an abortion, lawmakers in Georgia, Indiana, Ohio, South Dakota and Tennessee propose banning all abortions except when the woman’s life is in danger, Stateline.org reported.
      If enacted, legal experts said the laws would be the first absolute abortion bans since the landmark 1973 ruling.
      However, some abortion foes worry that state bans could backfire especially since five pro-Roe justices remain in the Supreme Court.
      It’s as predictable as the sun rising that lower courts would strike down such state bans, said Americans United for Life Director Clarke Forsythe.
      It would be better to pass legislation "that can be enforced," such as parental notification requirements and fetal pain warnings, the constitutional lawyer told the state issues organization.
I agree that it may be too soon to declare "victory", but I have to agree with Maggie Gallagher that it’s time to start getting ready for life in a post-Roe America.
The latest news on this front is, according to the Reuters article, "South Dakota passes abortion ban".  (See the previous article "S.D. Closer to Strict Abortion Limits" as well.) Like I said before, I think it’s a bit early or premature to be doing this challenge while the court still appears to be 5-4 for Roe v. Wade to stand as is.  There are now 5 Catholics on the Supreme Court, but only 4 of them appear to be pro-life – Justice Kennedy is almost definitely pro-choice, unless this is true. (of course, it isn’t – here’s the original story from the Curt Jester)
I thought this was interesting:
The bill as written does make an exception if the fetus dies during a doctor’s attempt to save the mother’s life.
Essentially this exempts the doctor from liability, if the fetus dies while the mother is being operated on.  I think this is a difference of semantics from the statements in previous articles that there is an exemption if the mother’s life is at risk.
This line from the article reminds me of an argument I got into during my lunch break with a woman on the Yahoo! message boards for the article:
"We hope (Rounds) recognizes this for what it is: a political tool and not about the health and safety of the women of South Dakota," [Kate] Looby [of Planned Parenthood’s South Dakota chapter] said.
The lady on the message boards (who goes by cant_sleep_clowns_will_roast_me and fabtemp2005) said in Msg 3155 that:
who wasn’t a member of the clergy who also wasn’t one of the following:
– Extremely overweight;
– Fairly unattractive;
– Financially struggling or downright broke;
– In a miserable marriage he felt he had to enter because of a pregnancy;
– Suffering some serious emotional instability issue, like alcoholism;
or some combination thereof.
Additionally, I have never met an anti-choice male (again barring clergy) who wasn’t also a racist, an anti-Semite and a gay basher.
That’s because misogyny rarely comes alone as a prejudice.
As the oldest brother of 6 sisters, I take serious offense to any charges that I might be a misogynist.  My faith and my upbringing teach me to honor my mother, to love and protect my sisters, to love my wife as Christ loves His Church, and that my daughter is to be loved as God loves each of us.  So, my final response, at the end of the argument was this:
How is it misogyny to be pro-life?

How is it misogyny to be against women having unnecessary surgery?

How is it misogyny to be against a woman losing her child?

How is it misogyny to be against women having increased rates of depression, infertility, and suicide? (this is just one consequence of abortions – see http://www.afterabortion.info/psychol.html and http://www.afterabortion.info/physica.html )

How is it misogyny to be against something that increases heart-break and failed relationships for women? (Read "Forbidden Grief: The Unspoken Pain of Abortion" by Theresa Burke )

How is it misogyny to be against something that increases the chances of having premature babies in the future? (See http://www.afterabortion.info/PAR/V8/n4/cerebralpalsy.html)

Is it not more misogynic to know all these risks and threats, and still be pro-abortion?

So, whether the fight to end abortion is a matter of convincing with reason, touching hearts, or overcoming prejudices and generalizations, this is going to require lots of prayer, sacrifice, and maybe even some donations (like the anonymous $1 million donation to the state of South Dakota to defray legal fees).  Good thing Lent is coming (Ash Wednesday is March 1st this year) – those are the three traditional practices of Lent: prayer, fasting, and almsgiving.
Please dedicate this Lent to the end of abortion in our country, as well as to the healing of so many wounded hearts and minds because of this century’s slavery issue.
This entry was posted in abortion. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s